New articles every Tuesday and FridayWhat goes wrong, and whyTested in an oven that heats unevenlyRecipes explained, not copied
Goûter Gourmand

Chocolate pastry cream

Chocolate sets pastry cream as it cools: a vanilla recipe with chocolate added comes out far too firm. The right amounts and the method.

Homemade chocolate-glazed eclairs, the chocolate cream visible at the side

Chocolate pastry cream is not a vanilla cream with chocolate added. Chocolate contains cocoa butter, which sets as it cools, and cocoa solids, which thicken: added to a classic recipe, it gives a cream you could slice. So the starch has to come down as the chocolate goes up.

My first batch of chocolate eclairs had a filling so firm it cracked the choux pastry as I piped it in. The cream tasted good, it had simply been thickened twice.

What chocolate changes in the cream

Pastry cream holds thanks to starch, which swells and gels at around 85 °C, trapping the water in the milk. It is the same mechanism as in a French custard tart, which is nothing more than pastry cream baked in the oven.

Chocolate adds a second structure on top:

  • cocoa butter, solid at room temperature, which sets the cream as it cools;
  • cocoa solids, which absorb water as a little flour would;
  • sugar, already present in dark chocolate, which has to come out of the recipe.

The result: with the same amount of starch, chocolate pastry cream is noticeably firmer once cold than its vanilla version.

Dosing, by use

Dark chocolate per 500 ml milkCornflourTexture once coldUse
60 g40 gsoft, light flavourtarts, choux
100 g35 gcreamy, clearly chocolateyeclairs, choux, tarts
150 g25 gdense, almost a crémeuxtart bases, glasses

Beyond 150 g you move away from pastry cream towards a crémeux, and the starch becomes almost unnecessary.

The reference ratios

To fill 10 to 12 eclairs or a 24 cm tart:

  • 500 ml whole milk
  • 4 egg yolks
  • 70 g sugar, instead of 100 g for a vanilla cream
  • 35 g cornflour
  • 100 g dark chocolate at 60 or 70 %, finely chopped
  • 10 g unsweetened cocoa, optional, for a deeper colour
  • 25 g butter

Whole milk matters, for the same reason as in the custard tart: the fat contributes to the texture, and a cream made with semi-skimmed milk is paler and more rubbery.

The method

  1. Bring the milk to a simmer.
  2. Mix the yolks with the sugar, then the cornflour and cocoa, just until smooth. No need for long whisking until pale.
  3. Pour a third of the hot milk onto the yolks while whisking, then return everything to the pan.
  4. Cook while whisking constantly, scraping the bottom and corners, until it boils. Let it boil for one full minute: this finishes gelling the starch and removes the floury taste.
  5. Off the heat, add the chopped chocolate and whisk until fully melted, then the butter.
  6. Transfer to a wide dish, cover with film touching the surface, and cool quickly, ideally set over iced water, before it goes into the fridge.

The chocolate always goes in off the heat. In a boiling cream it can catch on the bottom and leave hard specks.

Smoothing without breaking it

Cold, chocolate pastry cream sets into a block. Before piping, it needs loosening with a whisk, for a few seconds, just until smooth again.

This is where many people go wrong the other way: whisked for a long time, or with an electric mixer, cold pastry cream turns runny because the starch gel breaks. Once broken, it does not re-form.

For a lighter filling, fold in a third of whipped cream: that is the principle of crème diplomate. A cream whipped with mascarpone, like mascarpone whipped cream, also works and holds better, which makes it a good option for a chocolate take on the strawberry mascarpone tart.

What goes wrong, and why

SymptomCauseFix
Cream too firm, brittletoo much starch for the amount of chocolate35 g cornflour for 100 g chocolate
Cream stays runnynot boiled long enoughone full minute at a rolling boil
Lumpsyolks cooked by milk that was too hot, or a scorched bottomadd the milk in two goes, scrape constantly, pass through a sieve
Hard chocolate speckschocolate added over the heatalways off the heat, finely chopped
Skin on the surfacefilm not touching the creamfilm directly on the surface

This is not a ganache: a whipped chocolate ganache is made from cream and chocolate alone, with no eggs or starch, and is meant to be whipped. Pastry cream never is.

Storage

48 hours in the fridge, with film touching the surface, and no longer: it is an egg cream, rich in milk, and keeps poorly. It does not freeze, as the starch releases its water when thawed.

Frequently asked questions

Can chocolate pastry cream be made with cocoa powder only? Yes, with 30 to 40 g of unsweetened cocoa per 500 ml of milk, keeping 100 g of sugar and 40 g of cornflour. The flavour is drier and more bitter, and the texture softer, since there is no cocoa butter to set it.

Why is my chocolate pastry cream too thick? Because chocolate thickens it as it cools, on top of the starch. A vanilla recipe with chocolate added always gives a cream that is too firm. Cutting the cornflour by about a quarter solves it.

Can I use milk chocolate? Yes, using 150 g per 500 ml of milk since it holds less cocoa, and bringing the sugar down to 40 g. The flavour is gentler and the cream slightly softer.

How do I rescue a lumpy cream? Push it through a fine sieve while still hot, pressing with a spatula. If the lumps come from a bottom that caught, do not scrape the pan when pouring.

A failed cake is not the end of it